long tales

Sometimes I wish I had gotten into Star Trek when I was a teenager. I've never had anything against the show, the various permutations that have followed, or their fans. Jealous of those fans, actually. I never watched any of the series. I saw a couple of movies. Like most people, I know who Kirk and Picard and Spock are. I just never watched.

Marvel is another example. I read a few comics back in the day, most specifically the original Dr. Strange series (I was a wannabe hippie, what can I say). And my wife watches the movies, so I've seen some of them. But I'm never quite sure who does what.

Doctor Who, Star Wars ... I know little (Doctor Who) or some (Star Wars), but I am no fanatic, and I don't get tingly when a new Star Wars movie turns up. Again, I don't hate them or their fans, I'm just not a part of that.

My jealousy comes from wishing I was a part of it. Star Trek especially ... there are so many series and movies that I could binge the rest of my life and not catch up with all of it. That sounds appealing ... not the binging, just the part where there is so much and you are part of it.

Then I realized, there is one area where I participate that is similar to what Trekkers enjoy: sports. You follow something over the years, as history builds up and each season brings a freshness you don't find anywhere else. The Giants are in Spring Training, and Pablo Sandoval and Hunter Pence are back, and they are "Good Giants" and I think of the past when I see them in the present. Johnny Antonelli died the other day, and he was a Giants ace pitcher the first few years after they came to San Francisco. I relate to the Giants the way Trekkers relate to Star Trek: a continuing story that I take part it, year after year, drawing enjoyment not just from the present, but from the present's connection to the past.

I've never held it against people who are "fair weather fans", who show up at Giants games when they are winning World Series but are absent the rest of the time. Why shouldn't they get in on the enjoyment? But when the Giants won the Series in 2010, it was especially sweet for those of us who remember 1958 and had been waiting our whole lives for that moment. Same thing with the Warriors ... I remember when they were NBA champs in the mid-70s, but I also remember decades of underachievement, and so their revival in recent years was particularly cool.

Maybe we all need long tales to help us survive.


music friday: high fidelity the series

High Fidelity the TV series is yet another version of Nick Hornby's creation. The trick here is that the lead character, a man in both the novel and in the 2000 movie with John Cusack, is now a woman played by Zoë Kravitz. The show is never a simple gender flip, but it still needs mentioning, since Hornby is sometimes considered the first "lad lit" writer. At least as important, though, is the updating of the story to 2020 (if nothing else, the idea of a show focused on a store that sells only vinyl records has a different feel nowadays). The casting is solid ... Kravitz is wonderful as Rob, showing all facets of her complicated and not always "nice" character, and the primary supporters, Da'Vine Joy Randolph (Cherise) and David H. Holmes (Simon), are equally fine. And Kravitz pulls off the "Fleabag" style of talking to the camera without being annoying.

Here is a Top Five Songs Featured in the TV Series list:

"Heart of Glass" turns up in a scene with Debbie Harry that matches a scene in the movie with Bruce Springsteen, right down to the dialogue being almost an exact match:

Bowie's album The Man Who Sold the World is featured in a mid-season episode where Rob fetishizes the album's original pressing (she is thinking of buying a collection from a woman played by Parker Posey who is getting revenge on her husband by selling his records). The album turns up at the end of the season, as well.

At one point, Rob puts on a Swamp Dogg record in the story, claiming "I will now sell five copies of Love, Loss, and Auto-Tune". Immediately, people in story ask, "who is that?"

In a marvelous episode written by Solomon Georgio, Rob gets a suggestion as a DJ to start her night by playing "Automatic":

In that same episode, Simon offers this analysis of Sylvester and "You Make Me Feel (Mighty Real)": "In the 70s, the only way to get a disco song on the radio was if the DJs at the gay bars played it. That was the first time we ever had any say in the record industry. Disco was the sound of liberation."


tv in the 2010s: binge these in the 2020s, part three

(Cut-and-pasted from an earlier post.) I don't write as much about TV these days. One reason is that there is indeed too much good stuff ... it's hard enough to keep up with the watching, much less the writing. But I've found a catch-all way to inject TV into the blog, AV Club's "The 100 best TV shows of the 2010s". It's an obvious way to make my point about too much good stuff ... the list has 100 shows, and I haven't watched many of them (about a third). (Not to mention the thing about all such lists: each of us wonders why our favorite show didn't make the cut? Shout out to The 100Lights OutAgent CarterSweet/ViciousOutlander, and Hot Ones.) What follows is a few comments about some shows I did watch. This will be a multiple-post thread.

These are shows you may have watched. You have all the time in the world now to catch up with them (they have all finished their run). Numbers are their place in the AV Club poll.

The Leftovers (7). I wrote a long post after the series finale, and it's best I just direct you to that, because it was a good one: "The Leftovers Series Finale".

The Americans (5). Another time where I wrote something that works here, so I'll cut and paste.

The Americans had its series finale ... it isn't on anymore. Except, of course, hardly anyone watches TV when it's "on", so The Americans sits out there, waiting to be discovered by bingers. On its face, it's a story about cold war Russian undercover spies. But more than anything, it's about family. The family on The Americans is on the wrong side of history, and we know that (it takes place during the Reagan years, and the spies, as true believers, don't know that they are going to lose). We care about them ... they are the center of the show. They are the "bad guys", yet we root for them. And they do despicable things in the name of Mother Russia. It is one of the handful of best TV series of all time. You should watch it.

It also makes great use of music. Every show nowadays has a montage set to music. Usually the music is crap, and the montage is a cliche. The Americans does it right.

Mad Men (2). Finally, a show everyone watched. Or at least talked about. Is it a better show than The Americans, or The Leftovers? At this level, comparisons are pointless. It will take you longer to binge ... there are 28 episodes of The Leftovers, 75 of The Americans, 92 of Mad Men. Mad Men is the one show of these three most likely to appear on college syllabi in the future, the most likely to be talked about when the history of television of the early 21st century comes up. I probably preferred The Leftovers, I think my wife preferred The Americans, both of us loved all three. Watch 'em all, then you decide.


tv in the 2010s: binge these in the 2020s, part two

(Cut-and-pasted from an earlier post.) I don't write as much about TV these days. One reason is that there is indeed too much good stuff ... it's hard enough to keep up with the watching, much less the writing. But I've found a catch-all way to inject TV into the blog, AV Club's "The 100 best TV shows of the 2010s". It's an obvious way to make my point about too much good stuff ... the list has 100 shows, and I haven't watched many of them (about a third). (Not to mention the thing about all such lists: each of us wonders why our favorite show didn't make the cut? Shout out to The 100Lights OutAgent CarterSweet/ViciousOutlander, and Hot Ones.) What follows is a few comments about some shows I did watch. This will be a multiple-post thread.

These are shows you may not have watched. You have all the time in the world now to catch up with them (they have all finished their run). Numbers are their place in the AV Club poll.

Mr. Robot (56). I read on more than one occasion that Mr. Robot lost its buzz after the first season. As far as I can tell, this is based on a reveal about the nature of the title character, as if once you know who Mr. Robot is, there is nothing left to watch. That's just silly. Yes, it matters than Elliot, the lead character played by Rami Malek, has dissociative identity disorder ... in fact, at the end of four seasons, you realize Elliot and his relations with others is the core of the entire series. (Malek received an Emmy for his performance, three years before he won an Oscar playing Freddie Mercury.) But Mr. Robot was also a complicated, if fictional, study of the possibilities of anti-capitalism, and the stylistic quirks of creator Sam Esmail were usually fascinating and rarely self-indulgent. (This clip, from late in the final season, needs a spoiler alert if you're into that.)

Rectify (26). One of the great TV shows of all time, Rectify somehow ran for four seasons even though no one watched. It's impossible to sell ... Death Row prisoner is released on DNA evidence and tries to make his way back into society, in one of the slowest-moving shows I've ever seen. Rectify was created by actor Ray McKinnon, known for Deadwood, Sons of Anarchy, and most recently Ford v. Ferrari. It was truly remarkable, and the only way you'll ever find out is if you set aside the time to watch it. It would be a star-making performance for Aden Young, if anyone had seen it.

Justified (21). The best-ever representation of Elmore Leonard on television. It ran for six seasons and featured a terrific extended cast, including Margo Martindale and Jeremy Davies, who both won Emmys for their work here. But even with all the talent on screen, the essence of the show was the relationship between Timothy Olyphant as Raylan Givens and Walton Goggins as Boyd Crowder. And don't forget the shout out to Karen Sisco.


tv in the 2010s: binge these in the 2020s, part one

(Cut-and-pasted from an earlier post.) I don't write as much about TV these days. One reason is that there is indeed too much good stuff ... it's hard enough to keep up with the watching, much less the writing. But I've found a catch-all way to inject TV into the blog, AV Club's "The 100 best TV shows of the 2010s". It's an obvious way to make my point about too much good stuff ... the list has 100 shows, and I haven't watched many of them (about a third). (Not to mention the thing about all such lists: each of us wonders why our favorite show didn't make the cut? Shout out to The 100Lights OutAgent CarterSweet/ViciousOutlander, and Hot Ones.) What follows is a few comments about some shows I did watch. This will be a multiple-post thread.

These are shows I don't think you watched. You have all the time in the world now to catch up with them (all but one have finished their run). Numbers are their place in the AV Club poll.

Penny Dreadful (76). Three seasons, 27 episodes. Interesting, off-the-wall premise: bring together figures from classic Gothic fiction, like Dorian Gray, characters from Dracula and Frankenstein, Dr. Jekyll, and the like. Nominated for a handful of Emmys in categories like makeup and hairstyling, which missed the point entirely. Despite the often ludicrous plots, Penny Dreadful was made more than watchable by its actors. Rory Kinnear was the best Frankenstein's monster since Bela Lugosi, but the show was carried by its star, Eva Green, whose fearless performance was both grounded and over the top. Green was a highlight of TV in the 2010s. Apparently a sequel is coming, but without Green, it is unlikely to match the original.

Terriers (54). The winner of my first-ever Karen Sisco Award for series that were cancelled too soon. Terriers only lasted one season, and no one watched (I wrote about the series finale, "Seriously, how many of you have even heard of this show?"). I wrote, "The acting was strong across the board, and the chemistry between leads Donal Logue and Michael Raymond-James was perfect. Though it was a buddy show, the female characters had depth … they were more than just time-killers, and the show didn’t just take the guy’s side, the buddies were flawed and the show didn’t try to apologize for their behaviors. The ending was very satisfying, and worked whether or not the show is renewed."

GLOW (45). There is a running theme with these shows, which all sound like they might suck. GLOW is the fond tale of the Gorgeous Ladies of Wrestling, an actual series from the 80s. It's funny, it's heartbreaking, and it is a complex study of women's empowerment. It's the one show here that is still running (there's one more season to come). A great ensemble of characters and acting, with special mention to Alison Brie and Betty Gilpin, who play former best friends who are enemies in the ring (Brie's wrestling character is the Russian "Zoya the Destroyer" while Gilpin's is the American "Liberty Belle"). I love this scene, and wish there was a better video that didn't include people at home watching. Brie describes a match between Zoya and Belle by acting out the wrestling by herself.

Halt and Catch Fire (29). Good enough to deserve a separate post. Since I wrote one in September, I'll just link to it here. A show that got better every season, especially once they figured out the main focus needed to be on the female leads.


tv in the 2010s: sense8

Sense8 (#84 in the AV Club's "The 100 best TV shows of the 2010s"). Sense8 was as ambitious as any series, ever. It was also fairly costly for Netflix, which felt the size of the audience didn't warrant the expenditures. That audience was vocal enough to get an extra, movie-length episode to wrap things up. Some of the expense came from location shooting ... Berlin, Chicago, London, Mexico City, Mumbai, Nairobi, San Francisco, Seoul, and Reykjavík. The concept, of eight people linked psychically ("sensates"), was often confusing, although the commitment of creators Lana and Lilly Wachowski and J. Michael Straczynski was remarkable, and even when the plot didn't make sense, you could luxuriate in those diverse eight, which included a closeted actor in Mexico, a female Hindu pharmacist, an African bus driver, a trans woman and her girlfriend, and a kickboxing woman from Korea. The series emerged from its fumbling in its fourth episode, one of many times Sense8 featured set pieces of the sensates interacting:

It made no sense, but it felt right, and we understood for the first time what the eight were living through. Of course, their connection made it possible for plenty of sex scenes with multiple participants ... if you don't have to actually be in the same place geographically, you can have some great group sex in your heads. The feeling of community among the sensates was extraordinary.

Part of being a member of a sensate "cluster" was that you all had the same birthday:

And somehow, you could help each other:

I loved this show. I honestly never really cared about the underlying plot, didn't care what sensates were or why they had enemies. I just loved the characters and the way they were presented. And when Netflix agreed to give one last episode:

I'm not usually impressed by fan attempts to bring back cancelled series. But there was something about the nature of Sense8 and its celebration of difficult positivity in hard times that made the show matter more to me than most others, and made its one-more-episode return special.


tv in the 2010s: the half-hours, part three

(Cut-and-pasted from an earlier post.) I don't write as much about TV these days. One reason is that there is indeed too much good stuff ... it's hard enough to keep up with the watching, much less the writing. But I've found a catch-all way to inject TV into the blog, AV Club's "The 100 best TV shows of the 2010s". It's an obvious way to make my point about too much good stuff ... the list has 100 shows, and I haven't watched many of them (about a third). (Not to mention the thing about all such lists: each of us wonders why our favorite show didn't make the cut? Shout out to The 100Lights OutAgent CarterSweet/ViciousOutlander, and Hot Ones.) What follows is a few comments about the shows I did watch. This will be a multiple-post thread.

There are so many excellent half-hour series nowadays. Something about the format allows the creators to delve deeply into characters, infusing the shows with humor but always about more than just the jokes. Most of these series make room for people who are usually shunted to the side, when they turn up at all. Here are a few more that made the AV Club list (numbers are their place in the poll). In reverse order:

Russian Doll (28). Almost too easy to describe: Groundhog Day only with Natasha Lyonne. But that limits the appeal ... it should read "with NATASHA LYONNE!" Earlier in the year, I wrote:

Pretty much everyone I've read who offers up an introductory review of Russian Doll says the same thing: the less you know going in, the better. The trailer, which you can find at the bottom of this post, does a decent job of making you believe you know what the show is about without actually telling you, so it's safe. But for the most part, it's true: you don't want to know anything before you watch Russian Doll. So what I say here will be purposely vague and fragmented.

I could mention the cast, which includes Charlie Barnett, Elizabeth Ashley, Dascha Polanco, Burt Young, and Chloë Sevigny, all of whom are great. (When Ashley and Lyonne get together, it's a marvelous blend of two wonderfully scratchy voices.) I'm not usually a fan of stories that are complicated enough to confuse me, but Russian Doll moves so quickly and Lyonne is so watchable that I didn't mind in this case. And I can't say I understood the ending, but it brought me to tears of joy. Go figure.

30 Rock (9). I've long maintained that our response to comedy is more subjective than it is for other works. 30 Rock is a comedy ... there isn't much else. You can extract contextual meaning if you want, but it's unnecessary. It is much more "normal" than Russian Doll or Atlanta. For me, it was consistently funny over 7 seasons and 138 episodes, with the kind of fine ensemble cast that is very important if you want your sitcom to last for 7 seasons and endless reruns. There were a few other sitcoms that critics loved during the same period (late-00s through early-10s). 30 Rock is the one I became attached to.

Atlanta (3). I gave the episode "Teddy Perkins" its own post. It was one of the most amazing episodes of television I've ever seen.

Wikipedia tells us "Atlanta is about two cousins navigating their way in the Atlanta rap scene in an effort to improve their lives and the lives of their families." It seems to fit into a popular type of series today that offers up the lives of people who aren't a part of the televised mainstream ... think Master of None or Insecure. Atlanta allows room for all the main characters to have their episodes, and we get to know them in depth. The show has taken some odd turns ... there was one episode that featured Justin Bieber played by a black actor. And Donald Glover called his show "Twin Peaks with rappers", which is both too easy and quite accurate. But more often than not, Atlanta gives us slices of life with an odd tinge.

Not the most recent episode, though. In "Teddy Perkins", we're introduced to an extremely eccentric man who looks like ... well, I don't know, like a man who used too much bleach on his skin. At one point, reference is made to Sammy Sosa (Vulture had a piece devoted specifically to all the pop-culture references in the episode). When Darius, who has met Teddy Perkins, tries to describe Teddy's face, he tells his friends to Google "Sammy Sosa hat". This is what I got when I did the search, although I knew what to expect:

Sammy sosa hat

It helps to understand that Sosa is a dark-skinned Dominican who uses bleaching cream.

Anyway, this is what Teddy Perkins looked like:

Teddy perkins

The story unfolded in such a way that you were never quite sure if we were seeing Darius having a dream. But the conclusion, with two dead bodies and a freaked-out Darius, seemed to suggest this all really happened. It will be interesting if next week makes any reference to this.

Oh, and the person playing Teddy Perkins? The show's star and creator, Donald Glover, who also appeared in his regular role as Earn.

One other thing ... the show ran over by five or so minutes (not all that unusual for an FX series), and had no commercial breaks. The latter added to the overall weirdness.


tv in the 2010s: the half-hours, part two

(Cut-and-pasted from an earlier post.) I don't write as much about TV these days. One reason is that there is indeed too much good stuff ... it's hard enough to keep up with the watching, much less the writing. But I've found a catch-all way to inject TV into the blog, AV Club's "The 100 best TV shows of the 2010s". It's an obvious way to make my point about too much good stuff ... the list has 100 shows, and I haven't watched many of them (about a third). (Not to mention the thing about all such lists: each of us wonders why our favorite show didn't make the cut? Shout out to The 100Lights OutAgent CarterSweet/ViciousOutlander, and Hot Ones.) What follows is a few comments about the shows I did watch. This will be a multiple-post thread.

There are so many excellent half-hour series nowadays. Something about the format allows the creators to delve deeply into characters, infusing the shows with humor but always about more than just the jokes. Most of these series make room for people who are usually shunted to the side, when they turn up at all. I wrote earlier about Fleabag ... here are a few more that made the AV Club list (numbers are their place in the poll). In reverse order:

Better Things (62). Has gotten better in each of its three years, and since Pamela Adlon is the only one in charge now, she finally gets credit for what she always deserved. The setting (a divorced actress raising three daughters) mirrors Adlon's own life, although the show is not meant to duplicate that real life. But it informs the show in the way Adlon is so connected to the situations that arise.

Girls (61). In some ways, Girls never recovered from a line in the very first episode: "I think I might be the voice of my generation. Or, at least, voice of a generation." The second sentence shows a strong understanding of the young heroine's place, but it's the first sentence that people remember, and without the second sentence, the first sentence sounds extremely arrogant. Since Hannah Horvath had many similarities with creator/writer/star Lena Dunham, many assumed Hannah was Lena. Girls had many flaws, but the relationships between the four girls of the title felt real. And it was the introduction for many of us to Adam Driver.

Broad City (34). This show would rank much higher on my own list. Always funny, Broad City was one of the best portraits of women's friendship to ever appear on TV or anywhere else.


tv in the 2010s: the half-hours, part one

(Cut-and-pasted from an earlier post.) I don't write as much about TV these days. One reason is that there is indeed too much good stuff ... it's hard enough to keep up with the watching, much less the writing. But I've found a catch-all way to inject TV into the blog, AV Club's "The 100 best TV shows of the 2010s". It's an obvious way to make my point about too much good stuff ... the list has 100 shows, and I haven't watched many of them (about a third). (Not to mention the thing about all such lists: each of us wonders why our favorite show didn't make the cut? Shout out to The 100Lights OutAgent CarterSweet/ViciousOutlander, and Hot Ones.) What follows is a few comments about the shows I did watch. This will be a multiple-post thread.

There are so many excellent half-hour series nowadays. Something about the format allows the creators to delve deeply into characters, infusing the shows with humor but always about more than just the jokes. Most of these series make room for people who are usually shunted to the side, when they turn up at all. I wrote earlier about Fleabag ... here are a few more that made the AV Club list (numbers are their place in the poll). In reverse order:

Vida (90). The formerly marginalized group here is Mexican-Americans. Showrunner Tanya Saracho put together a crew of all-Latinx writers (mostly women) and expanded this into the crew in general. Vida has a strong queer feel, and won a GLAAD media award. It introduced new-to-me actors Melissa Barrera, Mishel Prada, and Ser Anzoategui. Season Two took the groundbreaking of the first season into a better series overall.

Master of None (87). Deserves to be on this list because of the phenomenal Season Two episode "Thanksgiving", featuring Lena Waithe, who won an Emmy.

Catastrophe (78). Sneaks up on you. Four seasons, 24 episodes, about an Irish teacher in London (Sharon Horgan) and a visiting American executive (Rob Delaney) who have a brief fling that leads to pregnancy and eventually marriage. Sounds blandly generic, but in the hands of Horgan and Delaney, it is anything but. Also features a solid supporting cast, capped by Carrie Fisher in her last TV role.


tv in the 2010s: david simon, phoebe waller-bridge

I don't write as much about TV these days. One reason is that there is indeed too much good stuff ... it's hard enough to keep up with the watching, much less the writing. But I've found a catch-all way to inject TV into the blog, AV Club's "The 100 best TV shows of the 2010s". It's an obvious way to make my point about too much good stuff ... the list has 100 shows, and I haven't watched many of them (about a third). (Not to mention the thing about all such lists: each of us wonders why our favorite show didn't make the cut? Shout out to The 100, Lights Out, Agent Carter, Sweet/Vicious, Outlander, and Hot Ones.) What follows is a few comments about the shows I did watch. This will be a multiple-post thread.

The David Simon Decade (numbers are their place in the poll):

Show Me a Hero (100). A six-part miniseries, typically underestimated by everyone but critics. This is based on the true story of Yonkers mayor Nick Wasicsko and the fight to desegregate public housing. Oscar Isaac starred, and the usual bunch of top actors were happy to take part in a David Simon show. Treme (68) was, to me, Simon's best show since The Wire. A story of the resilience of New Orleans residents in the face of natural disaster and governmental neglect, it was also a musical showcase, featuring great music every episode. Notably absent from the list: Generation Kill, about soldiers in the Iraq war that worked Simon's favorite theme of institutional incompetence preventing good people from doing their job, and The Deuce, about the sex industry in the 1970s and 1980s that had more problems than is normal for a Simon series, but had some great acting. [Edited because Generation Kill was actually 2008.]

All Hail Phoebe Waller-Bridge:

She was not the best thing about Broadchurch (91), but she was in the second season. You should binge that show, and not just because of Phoebe. Her great triumph, of course, was Fleabag (10), one of the defining shows of its time, the thing that put Waller-Bridge over the top. Killing Eve (59) featured fascinating acting from Sandra Oh and Jodie Comer, and Waller-Bridge was in charge of the first season. She had less to do with Season Two, and it wasn't as good.

The jump suit that took over the fashion world: