dear zachary: a letter to a son about his father (kurt kuenne, 2008)
Saturday, December 14, 2024
This is the fifth bonus film I have watched in "My Letterboxd Season Challenge 2024-25", a "33-week-long community challenge" where "you must watch one previously unseen film that fits the criteria of the theme for the week." This is the 10th annual challenge, and my sixth time participating (previous years can be found at "2019-20", "2020-21", "2021-22", "2022-23", and 2023-24). Bonus Week 5 is called "Past Hosts Week":
When Benjamin Milot took on hosting duties as the third host in LSC 4 he created a theme to honor past hosts' favorite movies that he kept going up until LSC 7, sometimes combining the theme with his own favorite movies list as the current host.
This bonus challenge is to watch a movie from one of our past three hosts favorite movies lists. Monsieur Flynn's (LSC 1) is here, kurt k's (LSC 2-3) is here, and Benjamin Milot's (LSC 4-8) is here.
I didn't expect to like Dear Zachary. I knew it was highly regarded, and it felt like a regular inhabitant of the myriad Letterboxd lists I have of films to watch. But it looked to be a true crime documentary, and I imagined something like the things that turn up regularly on television programs like Dateline NBC: a voyeuristic account of a real tragedy involving real people. It's true, my sense of those programs is biased in useless ways, since I don't watch them and so don't actually know if my description of them is accurate. I still don't know.
But Kurt Kuenne is up to something different with his film, something more personal, something that rejects voyeurism to focus on the real tragedy and the real people. Most obviously, Kuenne was a childhood friend of the victim, Andrew Bagby. He couldn't treat the story dispassionately, because he was among the mourners. He dealt with it in his own way ... he was a filmmaker.
The story took a turn when the woman accused of Andrew's murder, an ex-girlfriend named Shirley Turner, announced that she was pregnant with her and Andrew's child. That child, when born, was named Zachary, which helped provide a focus for Kuenne. He would make a film about his friend, one that his son could watch in the future to see what kind of a man his father was. It wasn't hard to get people to agree to be interviewed, because Andrew was universally liked.
The story takes further turns that I will avoid here in the name of spoiler prevention. Suffice to say that the case overall resulted in changes to Canadian law.
The point is, the personal experiences of Kuenne and Andrew's family, friends, and colleagues raise the film above something you watch on a Friday night to pass the time. Dear Zachary carries an emotional wallop that I wasn't expecting.
Here is a short film about the aftermath. Do not watch unless you have already seen Dear Zachary.