music friday: 1994
seven days in may (john frankenheimer, 1964)

by request: hell is for heroes (don siegel, 1962)

Don Siegel is a solid director who knows what to do with certain projects. He made Riot in Cell Block 11 for $300,000. My favorite of his films, Invasion of the Body Snatchers, went for a bit over $400k. Sam Peckinpah was involved in those films and others, and he considered Siegel a mentor. Siegel directed a movie starring Fabian. He directed one of Elvis' more highly-regarded films, the western Flaming Star (that came just before Hell Is for Heroes). He directed five movies with Clint Eastwood, who is the clearest example of a Siegel-influenced director.

He wasn't the kind of director who knew what to do with every project, though. His last movie, Jinxed!, is known for the rancor on set between Siegel, Bette Midler, and Ken Wahl. Siegel had a heart attack and never directed again. (And really, there isn't anything you can do with a Fabian movie.)

Hell If for Heroes is one of his better films. Star Steve McQueen was, well, Star Steve McQueen, but the movie got done without anyone killing each other, although McQueen and Siegel might have been tempted. (Add Bobby Darin to the list of pop stars Siegel directed, and also actors who quarreled with McQueen. Overhearing someone saying that McQueen was his own worst enemy, Darin famously replied, "Not while I'm still alive".) Once again, Siegel was working with an insufficient budget ... the ambiguous ending came mostly because they ran out of money.

The war action is intense, and Siegel doesn't make the common mistake of presenting his actors in such a way that their heroism overcomes any anti-war sentiments in the film. McQueen is a bit nuts, there's no real outcome to the soldiers' mission, some people die, war goes on. It mostly works ... Hell Is for Heroes is Don Siegel at near his best.

There is one particularly odd big of casting. Bob Newhart had become all the rage for his comedy albums, and the studio wanted him in this movie, which would be his first. His presence is rather like Ricky Nelson's in Rio Bravo ... give the kid a couple of songs and keep him out of the way otherwise. Newhart's character quickly ends up with a phone, and he spends much of his screen time concocting fake telephone conversations to fool the Nazis. Since his comedy act was almost entirely Newhart pretending to talk on a phone, these scenes turn out to be hilarious for the wrong reasons ... you can't help but laugh at the idea of Bob Newhart in a war film, talking on a fake phone.

Hell Is for Heroes isn't great, but it's a cut above other similar films, which is about the best you get from Don Siegel: a cut above.



Nihilist nirvana. This film was a chapter of my dissertation. By the early 60s, the Hollywood war was going to some very dark places. I talked about it in part in relation to the hipster persona.

Steven Rubio

I love this! It predates the 60s, but a favorite of mine is Attack!, although I don't know if it was a Hollywood movie.


Oh, yeah, Attack was another chapter. Aldrich was always good with mealy-mouthed liberals.

Steven Rubio

I really enjoyed the Aldrich movies that I liked ... I suppose that's a silly and obvious thing to say, but the difference between, say, Attack! and Emperor of the North is pretty large.

Steven Rubio

I also liked Alfred Molina as Aldrich in the Feud TV series.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)