dan hicks and me
spoiling perfectly good shows

oscar nom: star wars: episode vii - the force awakens (j.j. abrams, 2015)

A few years ago, in a post about The Empire Strikes Back, I wrote, “it’s time to admit that I am not the audience for these films. That was clear when the new trilogy came along … only Revenge of the Sith was even tolerable to me. But the fact that I don’t have any real desire to watch Star Wars movies over and over, even as I’m always ready to sit through Attack of the Crab Monsters one more time, says it all.” This holds true for the new Star Wars movie, which I finally saw almost two months after its release.

How does it compare to other Star Wars movies? I’d say it’s a contender with The Empire Strikes Back for the best of the series. But never have personal taste preferences been more illuminating. Watching Episode VII, I got the feeling the true fans of the series probably like this one, which is respectful to traditions (hello, Harrison Ford and Carrie Fisher) while moving forward in good and entertaining ways (hello, Daisy Ridler and John Boyega). Casting Adam Driver was also perfect ... the first time he takes off his helmet and speaks in his unmistakable accent, we understand the emotional turmoil inside the character. Not everything is good, again if we’re talking about my preferences. I had thought to myself, “at least we don’t have to put up with that damned C-3PO”, and within minutes, the sucker turned up.

The key for fans is to place the film in the context of the series. But that’s useless for someone like me, who doesn’t care about the series. Which is why my saying it’s arguably the best movie in that series is largely irrelevant. Because once I compare Episode VII to other movies I like, Star Wars doesn’t do well. For my tastes, there was a superb action picture in 2015, one that extended a favorite series of mine, one that I greatly anticipated, and one that fulfilled my every hope: Mad Max: Fury Road. But is Fury Road a better movie than Episode VII, or does it just better match my tastes? I prefer stunts done by humans to space ships fighting each other, CGI style. But that’s not fair to Star Wars, which is a space opera ... it’s not like they can put stunt people on space ships. I do think Fury Road has visual creativity that the Star Wars series has rarely approached ... think of the men on the poles, or the flame-throwing guitar.

I enjoyed Daisy Ridler, and was reminded of how revolutionary it seemed in the first film when Leia was part of the action scenes. We’ve moved far beyond that, now. John Boyega presented a different problem ... one more time, from my perspective. He was in Attack the Block, a favorite of mine that cost around $13 million to make. Is Attack the Block a better movie than The Force Awakens? Let’s just say I liked it more.

When a movie gets five Oscar nominations and none of them are “people” categories like picture or director or acting, I am wary. Episode VII is nominated in editing and sound and visual effects and soundtrack. If we compare it to other films that pile up the nominations in these kinds of categories, I think The Force Awakens looks quite good. But I’m guessing I'll watch Attack the Block again a few more times before I ever get around to watching this Star Wars movie a second time. To say nothing of Attack of the Crab Monsters. 7/10.



I think I'm getting a feeling for your "7" rating. That said, I think this has a lot of the same things that made Fury Road great, just that the genre they're doing it in is different (and maybe a tougher sell). I'm happy you went crazy for at least one of them.

Steven Rubio

Yes, I don't know if I explained myself very well, but I definitely felt like this movie was to Star Wars fans as Fury Road was to Max fans. Honestly, I expected to actively hate it, and was glad to be wrong.

I start at 6. If I like a movie, it's a 7. If it's just OK, it's a 6. If it's something special, 8. If I don't like it, 5. If it's a potential classic, 9. If it's no good, 4. If it's a classic, 10. If I hate it, 3. If it's so bad it's good, 1 with an asterisk. Examples:

10: The Godfather
9: Children of Men
8: Attack the Block
7: Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein
6: Gladiator
5: The Breakfast Club
4: Batman & Robin
3: Lethal Weapon 4
2: The Postman
1: Robot Monster

Or, in Star Wars terms:

7: Empire Strikes Back
6: Revenge of the Sith
5: Attack of the Clones

Or, in James Bond terms:

9: From Russia With Love
8: On Her Majesty's Secret Service
7: Spectre
6: Never Say Never Again
5: The World Is Not Enough
3: Moonraker
2: A View to a Kill


Goldfinger 10?

Steven Rubio

Goldfinger is a 9, which is another way of saying I guess I don't think there is a perfect James Bond movie. Because I have seen them all, literally, with the exception of the TV episode from the early 50s. I have a real attachment to them. Goldfinger set the template, for sure. As I have said, On Her Majesty's Secret Service is a George Lazenby away from being a 10.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)